Growth shares give employees ownership when they acquire the shares and typically pay out only above an agreed hurdle. Enterprise Management Incentives (EMI) options give eligible employees the right to acquire shares later at an exercise price. Ordinary shares can give immediate ownership and a claim on value already built into the business. The articles and option terms determine voting rights, dividends and what each person receives on exit.
Start by deciding whether the employee should become a shareholder now or at exercise, then compare cash cost, dilution and exit proceeds under the same assumptions.
Growth shares vs EMI options vs ordinary shares at a glance
| Compare | Ordinary shares | Growth shares | EMI options |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ownership timing | Shares acquired now | Shares acquired now | Underlying shares acquired on exercise |
| Economic participation | Depends on class rights | Commonly above a defined hurdle | Depends on underlying class and exercise terms |
| Cash requirement | Acquisition price and any tax | Acquisition price and any tax | Exercise cost and applicable tax position |
| Dilution analysis | Issued cap table and rights | Issued cap table plus waterfall | Fully diluted cap table before exercise |
| Valuation task | Relevant shares at the relevant date | Allocate equity value to the class using its hurdle and rights | Grant-date value of underlying shares, including AMV and UMV where relevant |
Worked example: what does 5% pay at exit?
Assume a £5 million growth-share hurdle and three possible equity sale proceeds after debt. The ordinary shares receive 5% of all equity proceeds. The growth shares receive 5% of proceeds above the hurdle. The EMI option is over ordinary shares representing 5% of fully diluted equity, with a £100,000 total exercise price.
| Equity sale proceeds | Ordinary shares | Growth shares | EMI options after exercise cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| £4m | £200,000 | £0 | £100,000 |
| £8m | £400,000 | £150,000 | £300,000 |
| £12m | £600,000 | £350,000 | £500,000 |
These figures assume all options vest and can be exercised on sale, with no other preference rights or adjustments. They exclude the upfront purchase price of directly acquired shares. The amounts illustrate payout mechanics. Grant-date market value is a separate calculation.
What ordinary shares really mean for ownership and value
Ordinary shares are the basic building block of company ownership. They carry voting rights, a claim on future value, and, usually, the clearest route to upside if the business grows.
That simplicity is useful. It also has a price. When you issue ordinary shares, you are usually handing over present value, not a promise of future value.
How ordinary shares affect dilution from day one
If a founder holds 100 existing shares and transfers 10 to a new hire, the founder retains 90 out of the same 100 shares. That is a transfer of ownership. If the company instead issues 10 new shares, the founder retains 100 out of 110, or about 90.91%. An issue and a transfer have different share-count mechanics.
A new issue dilutes existing percentages by increasing the denominator; a transfer reallocates the existing shares. Rights, tax, approvals and payment can differ between the two transactions. Decide which transaction is actually proposed before discussing its economic effect.
For a growing business, that can feel expensive. You are not only sharing future upside, you are also sharing what the company is worth today.
Why ordinary shares can make valuation feel higher
Ordinary shares are usually priced against the company’s current worth. If the business already has strong prospects, that price can be higher than founders expect.
This matters when you are issuing shares to staff, co-founders or early backers. If the shares are issued below market value, the discount can create tax issues. An employment-related acquisition below market value can trigger an income tax charge. For restricted shares, ask your tax adviser whether a joint section 431 election is appropriate. If used, it must generally be made within 14 days of acquisition. See HMRC’s guidance on restricted securities elections.
Ordinary shares are simple, but they hand over today’s value as well as tomorrow’s.
How to value growth shares with a hurdle
Growth shares are a special share class built to capture value only above an agreed starting point. That starting point is usually called the hurdle value.
In plain English, they let the current owners keep the value already built into the company. The people receiving growth shares only share in what comes next.
That makes them useful where the goal is to reward performance, not hand over the cake that is already on the table.
The hurdle value and why it matters to the cap table
The hurdle is the line in the sand. If the company is worth £2m today, the growth shares may only benefit once value rises above £2m.
That changes the valuation story. The valuer allocates equity value to the class by modelling its rights, the hurdle and the distribution of proceeds in different outcomes. A class can have positive market value at issue even if it would receive nothing on an immediate sale, because future upside can still have value.
The hurdle needs care. Set it too low, and you may give away too much value. Set it too high, and the shares may lose their commercial appeal. A weak valuation here causes problems later, especially if HMRC or investors question the basis.
When growth shares can be a better fit than ordinary shares
Growth shares often suit family businesses, founder-led companies and ambitious SMEs. They work well where the owners want to keep control but share upside with the people helping the business grow.
They can also feel fairer. If someone is joining after a lot of value has already been created, it makes more sense to reward future growth rather than grant them a slice of yesterday’s work.
For many private companies, that is the clean middle ground. It keeps the cap table focused and avoids handing over more than needed.
How EMI option share valuation works
EMI options are different again. An option is not a share. It is the right to buy shares later, usually at a set price.
An option holder does not own the underlying shares until exercise, but unexercised options still matter to the fully diluted cap table and future fundraising economics. Distinguish the value of underlying shares, the exercise price and any separate accounting valuation of the option.
EMI offers tax advantages where the company, employee and option meet the scheme conditions. Check eligibility and the applicable rules at grant, and review potential disqualifying events before exercise. See GOV.UK’s EMI eligibility and tax guidance.
EMI actual and unrestricted market value
HMRC offers a voluntary EMI share valuation agreement service. A company may request agreement before grant, but agreement is not a condition every EMI grant must satisfy. The proposed value still needs support. See HMRC’s EMI valuation guidance.
Where obtained, agreement provides a defined valuation reference subject to its terms and the relevant facts. It does not approve every aspect of the company, employee eligibility or option arrangement. Keep the evidence and review value-affecting changes before grant.
Actual market value (AMV) reflects relevant restrictions on the underlying shares. Unrestricted market value (UMV) disregards those restrictions and is used for EMI limits. AMV can help assess whether the exercise price is discounted for tax purposes. To request agreement, submit VAL231. HMRC’s agreement usually lasts 90 days from its date, provided there are no changes that could affect the share value before grant. See HMRC’s valuation agreement process and our EMI valuation checklist. For a worked AMV and UMV calculation and the submission process, see our EMI option valuation guide.
How EMI options differ from giving shares now
Option holders do not own the underlying shares until exercise. However, relevant options belong in the fully diluted ownership analysis before exercise; granting them can change the expected future economics even without an immediate increase in issued share capital.
The grant-date share value, exercise price and rights can affect the tax analysis and commercial reward. Fully diluted ownership should include relevant option commitments before exercise. Test the expected exercise funding and liquidity rather than assuming that an option is valuable only when it is exercised.
It is a clean fit for scaling companies, as long as they qualify and the plan is set up properly.
What to check before issuing shares or options
What founders need to watch when setting share prices
A low price can create tax risk. A high price can kill the incentive.
There are three things to get right:
- The starting value needs to be defendable.
- The upside split needs to make commercial sense.
- The paperwork needs to match the deal you think you are giving.
Get one of those wrong, and the structure can look neat on paper but cause trouble in a funding round or exit.
How the choice can affect investor and buyer confidence
Investors and acquirers read the cap table closely. They want to see who owns what, what has been promised to staff, and how much dilution is waiting in the wings.
Clean share arrangements help. So do valuations that are properly documented and hard to challenge.
If the structure looks vague, or the numbers feel inflated, due diligence gets slower and harder. That has a habit of affecting price too.
How to choose the right structure for a growing business
The right choice depends on what you are trying to do. If you want simple ownership, ordinary shares may be enough. If you want to reward future growth without handing over existing value, growth shares may suit better. If you want a tax-efficient staff incentive and your company qualifies, EMI options often make the most sense.
Think about stage, cash flow, investment plans and exit timing. A structure that works at seed stage may look clumsy once a funding round is close.
Talk to an ICAEW-regulated Corporate Finance Adviser today.
When ordinary shares are the simplest answer
Ordinary shares can be right for co-founders, simple ownership splits and businesses that do not need a fancy incentive plan. They are easy to explain and easy to hold.
That said, simplicity only helps if the tax and dilution trade-offs are acceptable.
When growth shares or EMI options are usually more strategic
Growth shares are often better when you want to protect value already built into the company. EMI options are often better when you want a tax-efficient way to reward staff, and the company qualifies.
If you are scaling, bringing in investment, or planning an exit, the structure should match the story you want the numbers to tell.
Conclusion
Ordinary shares give immediate ownership. Growth shares reward future upside above a hurdle. EMI options delay ownership until exercise and can offer tax advantages if the qualifying conditions are met.
The best choice depends on your goals, growth stage and exit plans. Get the valuation right early, and you avoid awkward surprises later, when the stakes are higher and the room for manoeuvre is smaller.
Ask four questions before choosing the instrument
- Is the objective immediate ownership, retention, performance reward or sharing an eventual sale?
- What can the company and recipient afford at acquisition or exercise, including possible tax?
- How do the rights work under a weak outcome, a moderate outcome and a strong outcome?
- Will the arrangement still make sense after the next funding round or a participant’s departure?
Use a fully diluted cap table alongside an equity-proceeds waterfall. The cap table shows potential ownership; the waterfall shows economic priority and participation. Neither replaces the other. A share-count percentage can look equal even where preference rights or a hurdle produce materially different proceeds.
For valuation support, choose the service for the actual transaction: growth-share class analysis, HMRC and EMI share valuation support or independent company valuation. Agree legal and tax responsibilities separately, then compare the resulting economics in a form participants can understand.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better for employees, growth shares or EMI options?
EMI may suit a qualifying plan that defers share ownership and the exercise cost. Growth shares may suit an arrangement that gives employees shareholder rights on acquisition and limits their economic participation to growth above a hurdle. Compare tax, funding, leaver terms and expected payouts before deciding.
Is transferring shares the same as issuing new shares?
No. A transfer changes who holds existing shares; an issue increases the shares outstanding. Both can change ownership, but only an issue changes the share-count denominator.
Do unexercised options matter for dilution?
Yes. They do not give current share ownership, but they affect a fully diluted cap table and the economics of future exercise or fundraising.
Does EMI require HMRC to agree a valuation first?
HMRC valuation agreement is a voluntary service, rather than a condition that every grant must satisfy. A properly supported valuation remains important.
Is growth-share participation the same as ownership percentage?
Not necessarily. A stated percentage may apply only to value above a hurdle, to a pool or to a defined waterfall. Read the actual rights.
Not sure where your business stands right now?
Book a free 30-minute call with Kish. Bring your numbers, your questions, or just your situation. You will leave with a clearer picture than you arrived with.
Book a Free Strategy Call