HMRC and EMI Share Valuation | Consult EFC

HMRC and EMI Share Valuation Services

Planning an EMI option grant? Start with the grant date and the rights attached to the shares.

What you can prepare before the grant. The valuation brief should identify the share class, rights, restrictions and intended grant date. If you are seeking HMRC agreement, HMRC’s guidance explains when to propose actual and unrestricted market values using VAL231. Bring the latest cap table and share documents to the scope discussion, and agree who will handle the HMRC submission.

Consult EFC helps UK companies prepare share valuation evidence for an agreed purpose and identify who will handle any HMRC submission.

Consult EFC supports UK companies and their advisers with EMI and other specified share valuation briefs. We agree the relevant date, interest, tax purpose, deliverables and any submission support before starting.

DefinePurpose, date and rights
AssessFinancial and commercial evidence
ExplainMethods, range and limitations
100+ businesses advisedWork directly with KishenICAEW Chartered AccountantSector agnostic

What to gather before an EMI share valuation

Share rights and capital structure

Bring the articles of association, cap table, proposed option terms and information on recent share transactions or fundraising. Confirm which share class the options cover.

Valuation date and responsibilities

Share the intended grant date and recent accounts. Agree who supplies the evidence, reviews the share rights and submits VAL231 if a valuation agreement is being sought. Read HMRC’s share scheme valuation guidance.

Tell us the planned grant date

The valuation brief

What does a tax share valuation assess?

A tax share valuation assesses specified shares for a particular statutory purpose and date. An EMI agreement request, a growth-share issue and a capital-gains post-transaction check are different processes. A commercial company value alone does not resolve the tax value of the actual shares.

The starting point

Define the shares.
Define the event.

01

The company and valuation date

Establish the relevant event and date, business position, recent transactions and financial evidence available at that date.

02

The interest and rights

Review the cap table, articles, shareholder agreements, preferences, restrictions and proposed option or share terms. Rights can make one class different from another.

03

The tax purpose and route

Agree what value is required, who is responsible for tax and legal advice, and whether a specific HMRC agreement or check process is available.

EMI valuation support

AMV and UMV need
an explained relationship.

For restricted shares under EMI options, HMRC asks for proposed actual market value and unrestricted market value. AMV reflects the relevant restrictions; UMV ignores those restrictions. Neither figure is automatically the last funding-round share price.

The supporting work needs to explain the company valuation, allocation to the relevant shares, restrictions, evidence and assumptions. Recent investment may be informative, but different rights, timing or transaction conditions can prevent a direct read-across.

HMRC’s share-scheme guidance identifies VAL231 as the EMI valuation request route. Any preparation or submission support is specified in the engagement; scheme eligibility and legal implementation require their own assessment.

Explore the detail

Choose the process that matches the event

Explore the distinction between three common routes. Eligibility, legal documents, tax treatment and filing responsibilities need to be confirmed for the specific facts.

01 / Define the purpose02 / Review the evidence03 / Explain the conclusion

Before the option grant

Define the shares and proposed AMV and UMV. VAL231 is the EMI valuation request route. Confirm the scheme, agreement conditions and grant timetable with the relevant advisers.

Explore the HMRC valuation service ↗

Timing and different tax briefs

Plan around the event.
Do not borrow another route’s rules.

HMRC’s EMI guidance states a 90-day period from agreement. Its valuation manual explains that the relevant concession can be shorter and depends on no substantial change in company circumstances or the market. Check the actual agreement and any value-affecting developments before relying on it.

CG34 is a post-transaction valuation check for relevant capital-gains circumstances. It is not an EMI pre-grant application and is not a general pre-approval route for employee share issues.

For growth shares, establish the actual rights, hurdle and relevant statutory basis. An EMI agreement process should not be assumed to apply to a different arrangement. See growth-share valuation and hurdle analysis.

What we can provide

An evidence-led proposal.
Responsibilities made explicit.

01

A scoped valuation analysis

The agreed company and share valuation work, with the relevant date, basis, rights, assumptions and limitations identified.

02

Supporting explanation and schedules

A clear account of methods, recent transactions, financial evidence and the relationship between company value and the shares concerned.

03

Agreed submission or question support

Any application preparation, adviser coordination or response work is expressly scoped. HMRC makes its own assessment and may request further information or disagree.

A clearer brief. Practical outputs.

Your EMI valuation pack: what the work should explain

The company value

A reasoned analysis of the business at the relevant date, using financial information, forecasts and relevant transactions. The method and key assumptions should be explained.

The shares under option

The cap table, articles, share class and relevant rights. Reconcile the company-level value with the interest being valued and explain the relationship between AMV and UMV.

The proposal and next steps

The agreed report and supporting schedules, with any VAL231 submission and HMRC question support explicitly included in the engagement. Identify the separate legal, tax and scheme-administration responsibilities.

01 / Before applying

Ready to grant

Bring the proposed grant, current cap table, share rights, accounts, forecasts and details of recent investment or share transactions.

02 / Valuation review

Evidence and explanation

Prepare the analysis and, where agreed, support the EMI valuation proposal. HMRC agreement is a voluntary process, not a guaranteed outcome.

03 / After agreement

Watch the grant window

HMRC says agreed EMI valuations are valid for 90 days from agreement, provided no changes affecting share value arise before grant. Revisit the position if the circumstances change.

A recent funding round is relevant evidence, but investor preference rights can make its price different from the value of the ordinary shares under option. Avoid applying an automatic discount or treating a proposed value as an HMRC-approved result.

See HMRC’s share scheme valuation guidance and its EMI valuation manual. Other tax valuations need their own purpose and route.

An agreed working process

Clear scope first.
Then evidence and analysis.

Clarify the brief and fixed fee

Agree the business, interest or asset, purpose, date, intended use, deliverables, responsibilities, fixed fee and VAT treatment.

Review the relevant information

Assess the available financial and commercial evidence and identify missing information or specialist input.

Analyse and challenge

Apply the agreed methods, investigate material assumptions and consider relevant sensitivities or allocation questions.

Explain the result

Provide the agreed deliverable and discussion, with limitations and next steps made clear.

Read further

Explore the evidence
behind the decision.

Your questions

HMRC and EMI Share Valuation, explained.

Is this an HMRC-approved valuation service?

We provide valuation analysis and agreed support. HMRC may agree a value through an applicable process, but this does not mean HMRC has approved Consult EFC, the company, the entire scheme or every tax consequence.

What is the difference between AMV and UMV?

Actual market value takes account of the relevant restrictions affecting the shares. Unrestricted market value is assessed ignoring those restrictions. The rights, event and statutory context must be identified before applying the distinction.

Is the last funding-round price the EMI share value?

Not automatically. The investment may involve different share rights, preferences, timing or conditions. It is evidence to assess, rather than a value to copy without analysis.

How long is an agreed EMI valuation valid?

HMRC’s guidance states 90 days from agreement. The actual agreement and relevant conditions must be checked, including substantial changes affecting value. A valuation cannot simply be rolled forward through a material event.

Can CG34 be used before granting EMI options?

CG34 is a post-transaction valuation check for relevant capital-gains circumstances. EMI valuation agreement requests use a different route. Do not treat the two processes as interchangeable.

Can you guarantee HMRC agreement?

No. HMRC can ask questions, request more evidence or take a different view. A supported report or application does not guarantee a particular value, tax treatment or agreement date.

Does the valuation include scheme legal documents and filings?

Only the expressly agreed scope is included. Eligibility, scheme documents, elections, grants and reporting responsibilities must be allocated to the appropriate advisers and company officers.

What information should we prepare?

The purpose and relevant date, accounts and management information, forecasts where relevant, cap table, articles, shareholder agreements, recent investment documents and proposed share or option terms are useful starting points.

What information helps you scope an EMI valuation?

Tell us the intended grant date, option share class, proposed recipients, recent funding or share transactions, and whether accounts, forecasts, articles and a current cap table are available. Do not upload confidential records through the initial form.

Does your work include creating the EMI scheme?

A valuation engagement does not automatically include scheme eligibility advice, option documents, grant notifications or annual reporting. We agree valuation and submission support and identify responsibilities for the other workstreams before starting.

Work directly with the adviser

A valuation with purpose.
A clear next step.

Tell us the decision, the interest or asset and any important date. We will help define the work.

Kishen Patel leads Consult EFC engagements. He is an ICAEW Chartered Accountant with a background in Big Four audit, investment banking and corporate advisory. Consult EFC has advised 100+ businesses and remains sector agnostic.

Our fixed-fee proposal explains scope, intended use, responsibilities, timing and VAT treatment before work starts. A free introductory conversation does not commit you to an engagement.

Not sure what information you need? Try the free valuation readiness scorecard to organise your starting questions. It is a planning aid, not a valuation.